MOUNT EVELYN STAR MAIL
Home » News » Additional charges for Alpine Hotel manager who sexually assaulted 17-year-old

Additional charges for Alpine Hotel manager who sexually assaulted 17-year-old

An ex-hotel manager at the Alpine Hotel supplied a teen with alcohol before sexually assaulting her, the County Court has heard.

35-year-old James Stewart pleaded guilty in the County Court to an additional charge of supplying liquor to a minor, sexual penetration of a child and common assault.

Husband and father Mr Stewart appeared at a plea hearing on 16 December where the victim impact statement was read to the court.

“This didn’t just affect my life, it changed everything about me,” the victim said in her impact statement.

“I could spend hours speaking about the emotional, physical and financial pain this has caused.”

Court documents show Mr Stewart invited a 17-year-old to his room in the early morning of 26 November 2023, where he prepared alcoholic beverages and asked her to sit next to him.

The 17-year-old told Mr Stewart, “I don’t want to do this” and he replied, “You’ll let me do this”.

The victim impact statement detailed how the 17-year-old’s mental health has declined severely since the crime.

“I couldn’t get any sleep without seeing him in my nightmares,” the victim’s impact statement read.

Alpine Hotel owner Rachael Northwood described Mr Stewart prior to the offending as “my number one guy in the business and the most senior person”.

She confirmed he was dismissed the day after the offending.

The victim’s impact statement included references to the 17-year-old’s history which wasn’t available during the initial sentence indication hearing

Judge Paul Higham said the nature of this additional information could potentially be an “aggravating factor” to the hearing.

“[James Stewart] particularly knew of a traumatic past, it certainly aggravates moral culpability,” Judge Higham said.

Forensic psychologist Pamela Matthews assessed Mr Stewart and claimed he reached criteria for a formal diagnosis of borderline personality disorder.

Her conclusion was based on Mr Stewart’s results from two personality tests and her “intuition”, as he had come across as “quite odd” during her assessment.

But the test results revealed Mr Stewart’s personality traits fell well below the clinically significant threshold for borderline personality disorder.

Mr Stewart will reappear in court for a directions hearing on 19 February.

Digital Editions


  • Cartoon: Hot Cold

    Cartoon: Hot Cold

    Award winning, Healesville based cartoonist Danny Zemp makes light of the wildly fluctuating temperatures in the past week.

More News

  • Three… ways to support those affected by the bushfires

    Three… ways to support those affected by the bushfires

    Donate to relief efforts The 2026 Victorian Bushfire Appeal, launched by the state government, is collecting donations that go 100 per cent to fire-affected communities. The government has said it…

  • Prepare for hard waste collections

    Prepare for hard waste collections

    On behalf of Yarra Ranges Council, welcome to 2026 and the second edition of the Star Mail News for the year. I hope you are all reading this relaxed and…

  • A subpar modern persona

    A subpar modern persona

    Sentimental Value Starring Stellan Skarsgärd, Renata Reinsve and Inga Ibsdotter Lileaas M 4/5 Nominated for seven Golden Globes, Sentimental Value is a comfortable but poignant Norwegian drama full of rich…

  • New data shows over 40 per cent of GP clinics now bulk-billing nationwide

    New data shows over 40 per cent of GP clinics now bulk-billing nationwide

    Healthcare directory Cleanbill’s first Blue Report since the Australian Government expanded the bulk-billing incentive to non-concession patients has been released. The government’s decision appears to be vindicated with the report…

  • Prepare early for hard rubbish collection

    Prepare early for hard rubbish collection

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 319962 Hard rubbish collection is just around the corner, so now’s a great time to start preparing your items for a smooth pickup. To…